Skip Nav

Juvenile Justice

Key Legal Decisions and Juvenile Justice Policy

❶Every day, judges and prosecutors make complex decisions about whether young offenders should be tried as juveniles or adults.

Should Juvenile Criminals be tried as Adults? (Argumentative Essay)

Bibliography
Popular Topics

Bullying has gone on for years and poverty has as well. So the bullying will continue for the less fortunate unfortunately. Why is it the less fortunate get bullied, you may ask. Bullying is another reason boys are more susceptible. Some may just feel it is a way of life. Unless their parent have instilled better morals and family values into their children.

We can expect children to become more and more deviant to try and test the waters of the juvenile justice system. Some may want to learn right from wrong but others will just follow the path of others for the chance of fitting in. The children may be able to overcome these obstacles if they are in a higher economic standard.

Yet, it is very difficult when you do not have the means or the background to do so. School, home, and up bringing has a lot to do with juvenile behavioral norms. It is like this all over the country no matter where you are you will find out the grass is not always greener on the other side.

Society has painted an awful picture of what things should be important and what is not. The lower classes try to put emphasis on family first but are afraid to show that they are in need of help. Gender, class; race, ethnicity, and delinquency are all linked together in many ways.

Yet, it is not because no matter what social class you are in the temptation of doing wrong is still there. There is always a person of any social, ethnical, racial background has the chance of becoming delinquent.

Depending on whom they hang out with or the feeling of having to prove yourself, it does not matter who you are. Yes the lower class has more of a susceptible chance of becoming delinquent because of financial hardship, family hardship, or even emotional hardship, but there is always that chance of it hitting the middle class and upper-class too.

Everyone has their own personal opinions that the lower class is all the problems of deviance. There is too much that can disprove this theory. If a middle or upper-class juvenile has been exposed to the gangs, and trouble in school or even if there is divorce in the family. The juvenile has the temptation to rebel and act out their behavior inappropriately. So where is the difference really except for the financial aspect?

Ethnicity, they say more non-white juveniles are a lot more deviant than whites. This deviance is due to a cultural up bringing rather than color or race. If you were brought up to be a gangster or hang out with those who were social deviants it is your choice whether you want to follow that path or not.

It is more of an emotional burden than anything else. When it comes to being socially normal all people should be seen as the same color and treated the same as everyone else.

It is also said that males are more susceptible to be caught in deviant behavior. This could be true. Females tend to try to stay out of trouble and just date the mischievous ones. Females do not have the overwhelming sensation to prove themselves in troublesome way. Females usually are more concerned about popularity in school and their clothing they wear.

The reason some females act out in a deviant way is because of social upbringing and their need to fit in and it is only as a last ditch effort to prove they are the best. Females usually act out in a sexual manner. The feeling of conformity to society is usually what brings in the deviant behavior. If society is overrun by gang type activity, violence, and other crime related activity you are more likely to have deviant childish behavior.

It is if a monkey sees a monkey must do society we all live in. If you have a good cultural upbringing and social norms to have the common sense or even the will power to say no it is better for the juvenile not to be deviant. There are differences in the areas where juveniles grow up. In the larger city you are more likely to have the gang violence and the shootings than you would if a juvenile grew up in a small country type town. Yet, the juveniles have the choice to be deviant even living in a small country town because; they have the overwhelming need to fit in or prove themselves to anyone and everyone.

Even the juveniles who go to religious schools have the need to fit in because of clicks and social and fiscal clicks.

In which all the troubles lie. Not knowing where or even how to get the help or are they going to be able to afford the help. In President Bill Clinton tried to raise the budget so lower income families could afford to get the health care needed, food on tables, and child care for those in need.

He also tried to get budget increased for juvenile justice programs —including anti-gang, violence prevention, and school violence initiatives.

Portner, Yet today they are trying to take it all those who cannot afford to work or physically just cannot work period. We are unable to defend ourselves because our voices are being overrun by the bigger cities such as Chicago. The book states that there are more blacks than white juveniles in our jails today because of personal and social upbringing and there need to fit have happened since slavery had begun.

They have had it terribly difficult trying to fit in since the early years due to the cultural and social integration of our nation.

They would all be judged on their integrity and ability to know what is right and wrong. Everyone is treated different but it is up to all of us to know how to handle each situation we encounter no matter how difficult it may be. Kids will be kids but what happens when little pranks turn out to be major problems in the future? That is where the juvenile justice system should step in. If we all could help one another, and watch over each youth we all could pay it forward.

Lend a helping hand where needed and help the youth of our society bring forward good values, fortune and the respect for the authority and the laws which our nation has built upon. I have personally have helped raise six children that were not mine by birth but, have called me mom because I was there for them they lived under my roof and treated me with the respect I deserved. Only two of them have become deviant and part of the juvenile justice system. They made the choice to move out and drink like their birth parents.

They were arrested for public intoxication and underage drinking because they thought it was what the in thing to do was. Since then they have moved back in and graduated High School, joined the military, gotten married and are living normal lives with their own children. The other four have also moved out and have been leading respectable lives and have stayed away from trouble. I feel so proud to have been a part of their lives.

I have three other children by birth that I am hoping that I can instill the values of the other six I helped raise. I still hear from all my kids on a regular basis and I have seven wonderful grandchildren whom I hope their parents can keep out of trouble. It pays to help others when in need. My kids are the most important to me even if they are not my own they will always have a piece of my heart and the knowledge of a better life than what they originally had.

It is a magnificent feeling to see them not in a life of crime. The relationship between juvenile psychopathic traits, delinquency and violent recidivism: In some cases they are waivered into the adult system automatically such as in homicide cases. Being tried as adults exposes these juveniles to state penitentiaries and sentences up to life in prison without parole and even execution.

But is this truly effective? Do these juveniles have the capacity to truly understand the crimes they are committing? Is there an age limit for introducing these juveniles into the adult justice system? Is there something or someone behind the acts of these young offenders? These questions leave us wondering if this notion really is effective or is there a better way of handling young criminals.

We have seen today in society how crime rates have been sky rocketing and how statistics prove that the majority of the crimes are being done by minors. I believe that when you look into the background of these young delinquents most of them come disproportionately from impoverished single parents homes located in disinvested neighborhoods and have high rates of learning disabilities, mental health, and substance abuse problems and with help of the juvenile justice system they can make a huge turn into a successful transition in to adulthood.

Their ages range from twenty and under, most are younger than fifteen years. He also discusses how many advocates and academics argue that juveniles are not being given enough of a chance to turn their lives around after committing minor offenses.

In agreement with Stier, I consider that juveniles have greater possibility than adults to make a change in their lives with the right help, counseling and rehabilitation.

Stier also states; there is new brain research showing that the full development of the frontal lobe, where rational judgments are made, does not occur until the early to mid 20s. Lexcen, Thomas Grisso, and Laurence Steinberg article: This being they are not fully mentally stable and developed in difference with adults who have full capacity and judgment to their actions this discarding criminal with mental incapacities.

They also argue the fact that in most states they do not specifically analyze if a minor is competent to proceed in criminal court as a requirement for judicial waiver unless he or she presents a mental disorder. Not all courts simple waiver them into adult trials some due follow a criteria in order to transfer a juvenile into criminal court.

Juvenile delinquents tried as adults have to assume the same consequences as any other criminal and are subjected to state penitentiaries with inmates much older and who have probably committed crimes far more devious then they could ever have. These minors range from the ages of nine to twenty depending on the crime committed or on how many times they are prosecuted and believe to be unchangeable. They are exposed to the harsh cruelty of penitentiary life where most are raped, beaten, and subjected to any abuse seen and known in these prisons no matter their age, mental and emotional state.

If scientists and psychologist who study the human brain and development determine they are not capable of full capacity and maturity and their brains are not fully developed as to rational judgment; what is causing them to do such horrendous crimes such as murder?

If someone is raised in a violent environment where they physically or visually experience cruelty, they are more likely to do the same. We have to realize that the people around us influence or actions and our change of character. Most young criminals are also controlled by organizations run by unlawful adults who promise them a way out of poverty and misery when they truly are shortening their lives.

The different situations are endless but I believe they should not be implemented into adult penitentiaries, especially those younger than eighteen. They should be placed with those their age group even though their sentencing can be that of an adult. However many disagree and they believe if these young offenders are capable of committing a crime like murder, no matter their maturity, they should be tried as adults.

We are not born devious and malicious; people are molded into who they become. It is common sense that humans adapts to their surroundings and are influenced by their upbringing that can determine who he or she may be in the future.

However I am not stating that is an excuse to do the same wrong. There comes a time in our lives when we have to decide who we ought to be. Do we follow the malevolent ways of those who surround us? Or do we make a difference and shine in the mist of darkness? Fagan discusses why science and development matter in juvenile justice. Every day, judges and prosecutors make complex decisions about whether young offenders should be tried as juveniles or adults.


Main Topics

Privacy Policy

Juvenile Justice essays In the society we live in today, juvenile justice is a nation wide concern of law enforcement. However to what extent the laws and penalties used towards the youth of today has been a major focus of many criminologists and organizations around the nation.

Privacy FAQs

The Juvenile Justice System is defined as that "sociolegal process having responsibility and authority for public reaction to current juvenile delinquency and deterrence of future juvenile delinquency, including within that process the public and private agents, agencies, laws, rules, and policies having to do with juvenile delinquency"(Weiner.

About Our Ads

Juvenile Justice Essay Juvenile justice has always been a controversial question because some people consider that children should be tried for crimes the same way the adults are since the harm is usually the same and, sometimes, the consequences are even more dramatic. Juvenile Justice System Essay Examples. 53 total results. An Argument in Favor of Implementation of the JV Juvenile System in the US. words. The Flaws in the Juvenile Justice System in the State of Massachusetts. 3, words. 7 pages. An Analysis of the Right Trial for Juvenile .

Cookie Info

The History and Evolution of the Juvenile Justice System Essay - The history of the juvenile justice system is a mixture of the criminal justice system, family court, child protective services, social services, orphanages, adoption and humanitarian growth. All those factors and others imply that the juvenile justice system should be coherently different from the adult criminal justice system. The rationale for behind giving special handling with young offenders is the idea of parens patriae (the state as parent).